The Praise Sandwich

Thanks for the submission. I think the author really nailed the genre and the atmosphere. I could feel it. The rain, the VO, the compromised hero... all great stuff. Leah was great too. Flawed, funny, smart. Good writing. It's a little messy. It feels overstuffed with plot: too many characters, too many chase sequences... but all that is editing.
​
We've all been there, right? The so-called "praise sandwich." A little praise. A little criticism. Then a little more praise to help the medicine go down.
Depending on where you are in your writing career, your reaction to that sandwich may determine just how far you're going to get in the business.
For the record, the "I'll do anything you say" approach can be just as damaging as telling the note giver they're as full of crap as the sandwich they just served you.
So where's the happy medium? Well, that's where maturity finally enters the conversation.
It depends on how close you are to the material. It depends on the quality of the note. Most importantly, it depends on how badly you want your story to work in what is, and always will be, a collaborative medium.
So here are a few thoughts on dealing with notes.
First, understand who's giving them.
What is their agenda? Are they frustrated writers secretly trying to sabotage your masterpiece? Probably not.
For the most part, story analysts, readers, producers, and development executives want their companies to succeed. They are not going to pass on something with genuine commercial potential simply because they're having a bad day.
Most notes are given in good faith. That doesn't mean they're always right. But it does mean they're usually worth considering.
Second, give yourself some time.
If your immediate reaction is anger, congratulations. You're a writer. We've all done it.
The problem is that when you're too close to your material, every note feels personal. It isn't. Take a breath. Sleep on it. Give yourself enough distance to evaluate the note instead of reacting to it. You may discover that the thing you hated hearing was exactly what you needed to hear.
Or not.
But at least you'll know the difference.
Third, know your story.
This is the big one. Addressing notes is not about adding scenes or cutting pages. It isn't about making random changes because somebody suggested them. It's about strengthening the story itself.
Every scene should lead logically to the next. Every character should have a purpose. Every beat should move the narrative forward. If you're an outliner, go back to the outline. If you're not an outliner, pretend you are for an afternoon. Look at the structure. Follow the chain of cause and effect. Make sure every scene earns the right to exist.
Most note problems are story problems wearing different clothes.
And finally...Congratulate yourself. Seriously. Most writers never get notes because most writers never get read. You did. Someone took the time to read your work, think about it, and respond to it. That's not failure. That's progress.
You are close enough for horseshoes and hand grenades.
Who knows? If you do the work properly and conduct yourself professionally, someday you may see your work up on the screen.
Now screw off. I have things to do.